Argument settler → The important questions
Is Cereal Soup?
Cereal sits in liquid in a bowl. That fact has caused more trouble than it deserves.
The case for
Soup can be a liquid dish containing solid ingredients, so cereal and milk arguably satisfy the broad structure.
The case against
Soup is normally prepared as a combined dish, while cereal is simply dry cereal with milk added; ordinary language does not call it soup.
Still arguing?
Stop pretending this is going to resolve itself.
Settle your own argumentPick Who’s Right is for entertainment. The main argument settler chooses a side at random.